1.
“The Western Wall is the
only remnant of the Temple”
This statement contains three errors. First, it's not the "only"- all four walls of the Temple Mount (Western, Eastern, Southern, and Northern) still stand as part of the retaining structure. Second, it's not a "remnant." A remnant is a small, leftover piece or trace of something that once existed in larger quantity. These walls are complete, massive structures, not small fragments. Third, they are not walls "of the Temple" but rather of the Temple Mount- Zion, the Mount of His Holiness. The Temple itself stood atop the Mount. The walls were built by King Herod to support and expand the Temple Mount platform. Today, the entire Temple Mount remains intact with its original infrastructure: the platform, underground chambers, gates, and architectural elements from the Second Temple period. The Western Wall became the focus of Jewish prayer primarily because Jews were forbidden from ascending the Mount itself for centuries, not because it represents the totality of what remains. The entire Temple Mount is the sacred site where the Temple stood.
2.
"The Temple will descend from heaven"
While some mystical Jewish sources discuss a heavenly Temple, these sources are not practical guidance but are to be understood on a spiritual level- recognizing that what we do is divine work. The biblical prophets, particularly Ezekiel, provide detailed architectural plans for a future Temple, clearly implying human construction. Rabbinical sources refer to building the Temple as a mitzvah- a divine command that requires human fulfillment. Throughout Jewish history, the rebuilding of the Temple has been understood as involving active human agency. The Talmud discusses practical aspects of Temple construction and service. Even mystical traditions that mention a heavenly Temple generally view it as coexisting with an earthly one built by human hands. Historical precedent shows the Second Temple was built through human effort after the Babylonian exile, combining practical work with spiritual preparation. Jewish tradition fundamentally does not base itself on waiting for miracles but rather on human action in partnership with the Divine. We are commanded to act, to build, to sanctify- not to passively wait for heaven to do the work for us.
3.
"Ascending the Mount inflames the Middle East"
This claim reverses cause and effect. The Middle East is not inflamed because Jews pray at their holiest site- rather, the denial of Jewish rights at the Temple Mount is itself a symptom of broader intolerance and extremism. For centuries before modern Zionism, Jews prayed at the Western Wall without regional conflict. Violence occurs not because of Jewish presence, but because extremists refuse to accept Jewish rights or religious freedom. Blaming Jewish prayer for Middle Eastern tensions is like blaming victims for the hatred directed against them. In fact, establishing genuine religious freedom- where Jews, Christians, and Muslims can all pray at their holy sites- would advance peace, not hinder it. The prophetic vision speaks of the Temple Mount as a House of Prayer for all nations, a place of unity. The real inflammation comes from those who seek exclusive control and deny others their heritage and rights. True peace requires justice and mutual respect, not the suppression of religious freedom.
4.
"The Temple Mount is a place only for Jews
This fundamentally contradicts the biblical vision and Jewish teaching. The prophet Isaiah explicitly states that the Temple will be "a House of Prayer for all nations" (Isaiah 56:7). King Solomon, when dedicating the First Temple, prayed that God would hear the prayers of foreigners who come to the House (1 Kings 8:41-43). The Talmud discusses the offerings brought by gentiles and their role in Temple worship. Throughout the Second Temple period, there was a Court of the Gentiles where non-Jews could come to pray. The Shalom Jerusalem Foundation advocates for universal access and religious freedom for all peoples at the Temple Mount. The Jewish vision has never been exclusivity but rather serving as "a light unto the nations," sharing the spiritual blessings of this holy site with all humanity. The goal is not Jewish exclusivity but rather ending the current exclusivity that denies Jews their rights while opening the Mount to become what it was always meant to be: a center of prayer and divine service for all peoples who seek God.
5.
"It is forbidden according to Halacha to ascend the Mount"
This is an oversimplification of a complex Halachic discussion. While some rabbinical authorities prohibit ascending, many others permit and even encourage it when done properly. The prohibition concerns entering the specific area where the Holy of Holies stood, not the entire Temple Mount. With proper preparation- immersion in a Mikveh and wearing appropriate footwear- and with knowledge of which areas are permissible, ascending is Halachically acceptable according to numerous rabbinical authorities. Throughout history, leading rabbis including Maimonides ascended the Temple Mount. Today, organizations like the Temple Institute provide guidance on proper ascent according to Halacha. The debate is about how and where to ascend, not whether ascent is absolutely forbidden. Those who claim a blanket prohibition often confuse caution about the Holy of Holies with prohibition of the entire Mount, or conflate political concerns with Halachic law.
6.
"Throughout history Jews did not ascend the Temple Mount"
This claim ignores extensive historical evidence. During the Second Temple period, Jews regularly ascended for festivals and worship. After the Temple's destruction, whenever permitted by ruling authorities, Jews continued to visit and pray on the Mount. Maimonides visited and prayed on the Temple Mount in 1165. Medieval travelogues and Turkish records show Jews regularly visiting the Mount during various periods of history. The Chief Rabbinate of the British Mandate period discussed regulations for Jewish ascent. The claim that Jews never ascended is a modern myth, often promoted to de legitimize contemporary Jewish connection to the site. The historical reality is that Jews have always sought to maintain their connection to the Mount whenever possible. Only when faced with absolute prohibition by hostile authorities- or in recent decades, by political agreements- was this connection interrupted.
7.
"Jews who ascend the Mount come to make provocations"
This accusation reflects prejudice, not reality. Jews ascend the Temple Mount for the same reason people of all faiths visit their holy sites- for prayer, spiritual connection, and religious observance. Calling sincere religious practice "provocation" delegitimizes Jewish religious rights and heritage. The real provocation is denying Jews the right to pray at their holiest site while permitting it for others. Jews who ascend follow strict guidelines, maintain respectful behavior, and seek only to exercise their fundamental human right to religious freedom. Throughout history, visiting one's holy sites has been recognized as a basic religious liberty. Framing Jewish prayer as provocation is itself an act of discrimination. If a Christian praying at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre or a Muslim praying at the Dome of the Rock is not considered provocative, neither should a Jew praying at the Temple Mount. The notion of provocation is a political construct designed to suppress Jewish rights, not a legitimate concern
8.
"The Dome of the Rock is a mosque"
The Dome of the Rock is not a mosque- it is a shrine. Architecturally and functionally, it differs from a mosque. It was built as a memorial structure over the Foundation Stone, not as a place for congregational Islamic prayer. Al-Aqsa Mosque, located elsewhere on the Temple Mount complex, serves as the actual mosque for Muslim worship. The Dome of the Rock has no minbar (pulpit) or mihrab (prayer niche) in its original design- features essential to mosques. It was constructed in 691 CE by Caliph Abd al-Malik as a political and religious monument, not a prayer hall. While Muslims may pray there, this does not transform it into a mosque any more than praying in any building makes that building a mosque. Understanding what the Dome actually is- a shrine built over Judaism's holiest spot , the Holy of Holies in the Temple - provides important historical and religious context.
Join the movement and make a difference in your life time!
-
With boots on the ground, when you visit Israel
-
With shares, comments and likes in your social media
-
With financial support from wherever you are on the globe
Worshippers praying from east to west facing the Holy of Holies where God's presence dwells. This aligns not only with the sacred architecture but with the universe itself, where the sun and moon rise in the east and set in the west announcing His Kingdom over all creation.
Zachariah 14:16
Whoever is left
from the nations
who came to Jerusalem ,
will ascend year after year
to prostrate to Hashem- King of All Armies.